For brokers losing leads to a slow reply
What it does, what it will not do, and how to tell if you need it.
A report on your own business, showing how long enquiries currently wait and how many were never followed up.
By Reece Rainer
spareday, Newcastle NSW
Last updated
13 September 2026
Read time
3 minutes

He was able to take our rough ideas, from concept through to reality. The site has provided an influx of new members, helping to keep our club viable.
A passion-driven, good-hearted and reliable service provider with the competency of a genius when it comes to software engineering, AI technology and marketing.
He created a stunning website for us that captures and nurtures leads with an automated email marketing system, which has filled a huge gap in the business and saved a lot of time (and money!).
Somebody worrying about finance at ten on a Sunday night enquires with two or three brokers at once. The one who replies first usually gets the application.
This is what automatic follow up does about that, and why the long settlement cycle makes the first ten minutes matter more than brokers expect.
In the evening and at weekends, because that is when people look at property and start worrying about what they can borrow. Almost none of it arrives during the hours a broker is free.
The days are appointments and the nights are paperwork, so an enquiry arriving at nine on a Sunday lands in a gap where nobody is going to see it until Monday.
The borrower, meanwhile, has just done something emotionally significant. They have decided to find out whether they can buy, and that decision comes with urgency that fades quickly.
By Monday morning that urgency has been captured by whoever replied on Sunday night, and it is usually a broker with something automated rather than one who is more diligent.
A settled loan is a significant commission plus trail for years, so a lost enquiry is not a small loss and there are not many of them in a month to begin with.
That changes the shape of the decision compared with a high-volume business. A broker does not need to recover many enquiries for this to be worth several times its cost; recovering one or two a year would do it.
The trail makes it worse. The enquiry that went to another broker is not one commission, it is a client relationship and the refinance in four years and the referrals in between.
A reply goes out within seconds acknowledging the enquiry and asking the handful of things you would ask anyway, then follows up on a schedule until the person replies or says stop.

The immediate reply is what keeps the borrower in your conversation rather than the next broker's. It does not have to advance anything, it only has to arrive.
The follow up after it is where the recovered work is. Borrowers go quiet constantly, for reasons that have nothing to do with you, and a second message a few days later brings a real proportion of them back.
It suits a broker whose enquiries arrive out of hours and who cannot realistically answer them then, which is most brokers who are not already doing something about it.
It does least for a broker working purely on referral from a small number of agents and accountants, where the enquiry is warm, expected, and will wait for a callback.
It does most where enquiries come from a website, a comparison page or an advertisement, because those people are contacting several brokers in the same sitting.
The measurement settles it. If your average first response outside business hours is already minutes, there is nothing here to buy.
A broking enquiry is worth too much to lose to a Sunday night. The fix is a reply that arrives before yours could.
Related reading from us: every enquiry answered in minutes, AI For Mortgage Brokers, Google reviews for mortgage brokers and the enquiry that landed mid-appointment.
No, and it must not. It acknowledges the enquiry and gathers detail. Everything regulated stays with you.
Yes, it says so. In a regulated conversation that is not optional.
A small number over a few days, stopping the moment somebody replies or asks it to.
You do. Every account, number and message history stays in your name.